Reviews
Cape Kidnappers
Course Rating:
Course Opened - 2004
Designer: Tom Doak
Review

‘The flattish fingers of land along part of the clifftops were ready-made fairways grazed by sheep, I played 15 of the 18 holes with my crew one day before we had built anything.’ Tom Doak on Cape Kidnappers

Situated on the East Coast of New Zealand’s North Island, Cape Kidnappers is a remarkable new prestige golf facility designed by American architect Tom Doak. The course occupies part of an isolated 5,000-acre sheep station and incorporates stunning sandstone cliff fingers that plummet 500 feet down into the waters of Hawke’s Bay. With a number of holes running toward and away from these cliff edges, and even routed along the bluffs, this is one of the most compelling modern layouts in golf with some unforgettable coastal views.

The Cape Kidnappers area is as significant as it is spectacular, the bay beneath having strong links to Maori folklore and the cape itself being named by Captain James Cook in 1769, after locals had attempted to kidnap his ship’s young Tahitian guide. The golf course site slants gently toward the cliffs, which then collapse dramatically down to the ocean allowing the golf, in places, to dangle right out onto the edge of the landforms. Given the glamorous nature of such holes, Doak found himself having to work harder to ensure that the golf away from the coast did not suffer by comparison. To his great credit the success of Kidnappers is the quality of these inland holes, many of which are dominated by pronounced ridges and feature demanding carries from the tee across vast ravines.

Greens throughout the course are excellent, a couple like 8 and 14 are a touch extreme but the majority are subtly tilted, often elevated and with clever internal contouring that rewards precise approaches kept under the hole. Due to the severity of winds that typically whip across the heads here, the fairways are very generous with Doak giving players plenty of width and only using bunkers sparingly. Unusually, given his strategic design philosophy, there are a number of ‘hit anywhere’ holes, slashing away wildly on fairways like the 2nd, 4th, 12th and 15th unlikely to cause too many out of position problems.

The layout starts away from the magnificent sea views, with the early holes routed across a broad sweeping landscape that gives little indication of the excitement to follow. With its left side collapsing hundreds of feet down into a cove and a split fairway offering two distinct paths into a plateau green site, the 5th is a superb hole and a wonderful introduction to Cape Kidnappers’ infamous cliff-side area. The next is a smashing seaside par three across a deep gully while other standouts on the front nine include the strategic opening hole and the plunging par four 7th.  On the homeward nine the real quality starts with the par three 11th and the long, falling 12th, which features a gorgeous Bay backdrop and follows an expansive shelf that narrows as it feeds into a yawning ravine. Perched atop a ridge, the 13th is then a beautiful short hole that falls sharply left into the ocean, its horizon green contoured through the center to feel much smaller from the tee than it actually is. Also worthy of note is the bizarre punchbowl green on the 18th and the brutal par four 17th, which plays along a gully before crossing a tightly bunkered shelf.

Most interesting of all, however, is the 15th. Named Pirate’s Plank, this is a long, wide and flat par five that follows a massive cliff finger as it gently heads down towards the edge of the earth. Bunkerless and strangely bland given its incredible surroundings, the hole basically demands two long and strong woods followed by an approach that is not overhit. On a property so visually dramatic, the only question mark some may have with Doak’s work at Kidnappers is whether an extravagant designer, such as Tom Fazio or Jack Nicklaus, could have extracted more from such a site. Certainly a hole like 15 would have looked very different done by another architect but there is, in fairness, a substance to Doak designs which the others sometimes lack, and there is no denying that his Cape Kidnappers creation is an impressive addition to the world’s golfing menu.

This review from Planet Golf